Article

Cancer landscape and its hidden charms


           

             Medical consultation has a contour and time frame of its own. A person with ailment sets up an appointment, and s/he is usually accompanied by family, relatives, and friends to meet the doctor, more so in our Indian social milieu. Over the years, I have gained some insight. She had reached to see me early morning, much before the hospital had started bustling with patients and health workers. As we finished, she got up from the chair and I moved around to open the door. Before that, she held my hand and put her head over my shoulder. “I did not get a good sleep last night. Your shoulder and neck feel comfortingly warm.” Then she slowly locked her arm on her husband’s elbow, gave the smile with her eyes open, before leaving the consultation room. I and my younger colleague had all the information on the desktop, in front of us. After all the treatments were over, the cancer had come back and spread over her body. We both were overwhelmed by her grace. Unquestioning about the failure of treatments, she and her husband showed to us the power of a human touch.

 

Medical Consultation

 

 

          Towards the end of the day, I sat down with a cup of coffee and looked around for any unfinished task before leaving the hospital. Out of nowhere, the event in the morning had a thread running back to join another one which occurred nearly thirty years ago. The world of health care has its own mind games.

         Sister Gowry entered my room, “Basavanna wants to see you. His son had testicular tumor and was treated by us.” Four years after working at Kidwai Memorial Institute of Oncology, Bangalore (Bengaluru now), I still faced the professional challenge of talking to patients and their family caregivers. The twice weekly evening bus rides to learn Kannada, at a learning centre of Bangalore University campus near the Majestic Circle, had made me comfortable to listen and understand, without any reasonable progress to ‘read, write and talk’. Communication, bilateral and multilateral in nature, is integral to the delivery of healthcare in any corner of the world. Suddenly, the presentiment of a disaster gripped me before Basavanna came inside. Has his young son of 25 years got sick again? I pointed at the chair across the small steel-framed desk, “Dayavittu kulitukolli “. In his farmer’s panche (the unstitched rectangular white cloth which covers the lower body waist down) and the bush shirt, both faded yellow after repeated washings, he put his cloth shoulder bag down on the chair,” Namaskara Saar” and then closed the door slowly. As I watched his movements, he put his right hand inside the bag. Instinctively, I blurted out, “Nanage Beda Swamy”. Basavanna took out and kept two bananas on the desk. “Nama hittalinalida balehannugalu, togalli daktar”. These bananas are from my backyard, I got for you. Early in career, you learn certain dos and don’ts. During the internship, soon after passing the MBBS, I could make out that sweet boxes, gifts etc. become the objects of gratification; and a doctor has no reason to be a greedy child for her/his entire life. Yet, the two bananas from the backyard of Basavanna were precious professional recognition of a cure for his son, and I accepted bowing to his desire.

     Going through the evening traffic of Delhi and reflecting on a cure and connecting it with a failure, gave me a sense of balance for the day. As the vehicles slowed down on a stretch of road from Subroto Park towards Munirka, I looked upwards through the car window at the beams of a flyover under construction. Desraj, the driver on the wheel got restless, “Teen saal ho gaya, kab kaam khatam karenge?” They are constructing this for last 3 years, when will they finish?

 

Cancer care in India has drawn attention since 1960s

 

        Those of us who have been in the middle of cancer care can understand its progress through war, by accident, and through serendipity!  From the 1980s, in a period of less than 40 years, the intermingling and interdisciplinary developments of several biomedical specialties have given to the mankind slow incremental benefits. From the low cure rate of less than twenty-five percent, at the present more than fifty percent are becoming long term cancer survivors after the successful diagnosis and treatment. The cancer survivorship is far beyond a new lease of life.

Cancer survivors are human assets

 

     Matchmaking, despite the thriving business built up on the vast platforms of matrimonial columns in newspapers, marriage bureaus and matrimonial website portals, is a unique social phenomenon in India. After I had explained that all the tests of his daughter were normal and she had become disease-free two years after the treatments for lymphoma, the father towered over me in a lingering manner. “Are you telling that our daughter can get married? Her mother is anxious.”  She was twenty-seven and the father, an impressive man with a soft voice, was a Professor at Delhi University. Invariably, a tall heavy built man with a timbre voice can strike a chord in your heart. I stepped out of the room, with the Professor in tow, into the out-patient waiting area of the cancer centre at AIIMS, Delhi teeming with patients and their caregivers at the noon time. It was a foggy and cold day, and I pointed at a young man sitting quietly with his mother at the corner of a bench facing the window. A brief exchange passed between the two of us. His daughter Nisha, a master in science, may find Sudeep, a software developer and a childhood cancer survivor, a suitable match for marriage. A few months later, the soft-spoken Professor and his wife sought me out to attend the wedding of their daughter at a banquet hall in Faridabad. After the Jodi took the phera, it was a different matter that the bride’s family members had to push my little Maruti 800 out of the submerged roadside. It was past ten in the night, it had rained, and I drove back on a nearly deserted road from Faridabad to Delhi a little valorously. A couple of years later, Nisha entered my tiny office room with a baby in arms and the husband fussing over both of them. They were on a short holiday from USA. 

    From Rudolf Virchow’s description of the origin of cancer cell in 1863; over a century and half of relentless studies have gone into multidisciplinary areas. The natural history of the tumors, surgery, chemotherapy, radiotherapy, medical imaging, molecular biology, cancer genetics, immunotherapy, and palliative care have progressed in slow incremental steps. The landscape of cancer is merciful on scores of health workers, who on a daily basis take the steps irrespective of a failure or a success. I can never qualify as a Roman gladiator to fight cancer, yet I can play the role of a matchmaker for the soul-mates.

 

 Declaration: Author states that the content has no conflict of interest and no financial disclosure. The names of patients are changed to conceal the identities for ethical reasons.

Author: Bidhu K Mohanti is an Oncologist, who worked as a Professor at AIIMS, Delhi; and is presently a Consultant at Manipal Hospital, Dwarka, Delhi.  


Viewers Comments


  • Dimple Bawa

    What a lovely piece of article tying together many lives with just one word, “cancer” Cancer is a social issue impacting community with roots through each and every cancer patient. Fighting cancer is hard and surviving cancer is an entirely different fight. Cancer changes the perception of life, it lets you appreciate your life way more better than before. I’m grateful to have you as my doctor... your kind support and care played an integral role during my course of treatment. You are the most humble human being I’ve come across... And I’m sure there are other people out there who agree with my thoughts. Thank you for being there for me. We all help each other stay strong... No one is strong alone!

    Jan, 26, 2019
  • Dimple Bawa

    What a lovely piece of article tying together many lives with just one word, “cancer” Cancer is a social issue impacting community with roots through each and every cancer patient. Fighting cancer is hard and surviving cancer is an entirely different fight. Cancer changes the perception of life, it lets you appreciate your life way more better than before. I’m grateful to have you as my doctor... your kind support and care played an integral role during my course of treatment. You are the most humble human being I’ve come across... And I’m sure there are other people out there who agree with my thoughts. Thank you for being there for me. We all help each other stay strong... No one is strong alone!

    Jan, 25, 2019
  • Dimple Bawa

    What a lovely piece of article tying together many lives with just one word, “cancer” Cancer is a social issue impacting community with roots through each and every cancer patient. Fighting cancer is hard and surviving cancer is an entirely different fight. Cancer changes the perception of life, it lets you appreciate your life way more better than before. I’m grateful to have you as my doctor... your kind support and care played an integral role during my course of treatment. You are the most humble human being I’ve come across... And I’m sure there are other people out there who agree with my thoughts. Thank you for being there for me. We all help each other stay strong... No one is strong alone!

    Jan, 25, 2019
  • Dimple Bawa

    What a lovely piece of article tying together many lives with just one word, “cancer” Cancer is a social issue impacting community with roots through each and every cancer patient. Fighting cancer is hard and surviving cancer is an entirely different fight. Cancer changes the perception of life, it lets you appreciate your life way more better than before. I’m grateful to have you as my doctor... your kind support and care played an integral role during my course of treatment. You are the most humble human being I’ve come across... And I’m sure there are other people out there who agree with my thoughts. Thank you for being there for me. We all help each other stay strong... No one is strong alone!

    Jan, 25, 2019
  • Tulika Seth

    Beautiful, in the patients journey few think of the doctor , who has to give continually. The doctor is a person and is affected by the suffering they see everyday. In our present mercenary world unfortunately even patients have become impatient . We are at a cross roads in the doctor patient relationship. Prof Mohanti's writing echoes of a gentler , unrushed era. He is a very kind person and brilliant doctor.

    Jan, 21, 2019
  • Upasna

    Beautifully compiled and written sir. It shows how the success of treatment and the marriage and baby are unmatchable rewards for the treating doctor, that oncology has its own rewards and they help us deal with the pain of seeing the patients fail. Your patients are blessed to have a doctor with such a lovely soul.

    Jan, 20, 2019
  • Ajaya Upadhyaya

    Dr Bidhu Mohanti's gift of narrating his clinical encounters projected through the prism of his empathy and sensibility should provide a gentle reminder to the wider society that Doctors are human too. This is of special relevance in the current climate, when the growing intolerance towards doctors' failings, real or perceived, has taken rather ugly and violent forms.

    Jan, 20, 2019
  • Ajaya Upadhyaya

    Dr Bidhu Mahanti's gift at narrating his clinical encounters through the prism of his empathy and sensibility should be a sober reminder to the larger society that doctors are human too. This message is specially relevant in the current climate when the growing intolerance to failings of Doctors, real or perceived, has taken violent forms.

    Jan, 20, 2019
  • Nirmala Srikantia

    Yes since our relationship with our cancer patients and their family members losts for years unlike to other specialities , they share many things about their life other than disease with us,their happy moments, sorrows all. we become match makers, family counsellors, good friends, travel mates and what not? These are definitely hidden charms of our profession

    Jan, 20, 2019
  • Sapna Jadwani

    Great Sir,very good article directly coming from your heart. You are a keen observer, dedicated doctor and above all ,a nice person.

    Jan, 20, 2019
  • Ashok Kumar Mohanty

    Very nice article.. A good and a sensible Doctor can really understand the feelings and emotions of the patients.. the Doctor having these qualities are really blessed ones and they are being treated as the living God for the patient. Dr. Mohanty who is my brother in law is of no exception.. very genuine and caring personality.. May the Divine bless him all sucess in life and give him the ability to serve patients effectively with high chance of survival..

    Jan, 20, 2019
  • Bibhuti Bhushan Pradhan

    As usual, Dr BK Mohanty presents here another piece of excellency, in expression of the subtle chords of compassion. It reminds me of a saying " Invitation to attend the funeral rites of an ex-patient is the best gratitude for a doctor".

    Jan, 20, 2019
  • Dr Indu Bansal

    It's a beautiful piece written with heart and soul. It throws light on feelings of a doctor as they treat patient's with terminal disease but more than that it shows the soft heart and a caring soul of an excellent teacher and a noble human being. It's so beautifully written that the reader can actually walk through the story and feel the threads and connect a chord as well. Impressive !!

    Jan, 20, 2019
  • Rabin Mohanty

    Prof Mohanti's simple writing skills about the most complex disease, his recollection of his conversations with his patients just shows his love for the profession he has dedicated his life to. His exceptional talent of story telling is an inspiration to any clinician. As a Paediatrician I have come across many forms of cancer in children and the evolution of early diagnosis by using modern genomics and applications of gene therapy has transformed people's lives. Prof Mohanti is my mentor, inspiration, friend, relative and overall a great human being. I will be eagerly waiting for his next writing.

    Jan, 19, 2019
  • Poonam Bagai

    What a lovely article. Hats off dr Mohanty. The joy of cancer survivors making lives together ; going on to live full lives ; embracing life after facing death.

    Jan, 19, 2019
  • Poonam Bagai

    What a lovely article. Hats off dr Mohanty. The joy of cancer survivors making lives together ; going on to live full lives ; embracing life after facing death.

    Jan, 19, 2019
  • CHANDRASHEKHAR PANDA

    Excellent presentation which is self explanatory of the talent, experience and especially the human touch of the doctor and the Author. I know Dr B K Mohanty as a family freind for around 25 years. Initially when I used to goto his residence in AIIMS I know him as an excellent host, Good person then could know him as a person with multi faceted personality - an author, actor and top of it a excellent human being. I had the opportunity to know him as a good doctor with human touch beyond our relationship when I was visiting Fortis Hospital Gurgaon for the treatment of my father in law. True to his article I had seen him the way he was interacting and informally treating other patients in the reception area in a very cordial manner, I could see smile in the face of the cancer patients and their attending relatives. To me its a realistic story line with positivevibes.

    Jan, 18, 2019
  • Sudhansu Mohanty

    Very touching, evocative, and reflective piece that brings out how a life-threatening disease can often sear a goodly oncologist's soul but also can warm his heart when he bears to see the nobility and fruits of his work. It touched my soul with its empathy, and with the feel - both of anguish and ecstasy!

    Jan, 18, 2019

Leave a Reply